Tata Motors Limited
Annual Returns


Cumulative Returns and Drawdowns


Ownership

Margined

Broker Narrative
The first report was a confident Buy built on JLR’s turnaround (FY24
FCF >GBP2b, >6% EBIT, ~200k order book) plus a domestic CV/PV/EV
upcycle and sharp debt reduction. By the last report the call had
dropped to Neutral, with JLR no longer the central theme and the focus
shifting to CV market-share gains, FCF, and exports versus commodity
inflation, supply-chain bottlenecks, EV cell supply, and Iveco-related
global/geopolitical risk. Persistent themes were CV/PV demand, market
share, FCF generation, and EV growth, while the earlier JLR-led
re-rating optimism gave way to margin-cost and capital-allocation
caution.
Fears that came true
- The warning that BS-VI Phase II advance buying would create CV
volume softness was echoed later by the high-base caution from Sep’26
onward, which could materially decelerate CV industry growth in
2HFY27.
- The early red flag on CV market-share erosion (Tata Motors Finance
CV share falling from 27% to 17%) was followed by renewed CV share loss,
with ILMCV losing 130bp YoY due to western-region supply
constraints.
- JLR’s anticipated margin/capex/forex pressures proved to be a
genuine overhang: from Jan 2024 onward the stock produced a long run of
DISAPPOINTMENT outcomes with negative actual returns as low as -37%,
even on Buy/Add calls.
Optimism that failed
- The early CV guidance of double-digit EBITDA margin failed to become
a durable margin story, as the last report still shows commodity cost
inflation (steel/rubber) pressuring EBITDA margins and input costs
expected to rise QoQ in 2QFY27.
- The JLR recovery/FCF optimism as a reliable re-rating driver did not
hold up in share-price terms: multiple positive calls in 2024-25
delivered negative actual returns, and the final stance settled at
Neutral.
CNBC-TV18: ratings, targets and commentary
No recorded CNBC-TV18 statements for this ticker.
Management comments
No recorded management comments with an explicit designation and affiliation for this ticker.
Copyright © 2023 SAS Data Analytics Pvt. Ltd. All rights reserved.
🐞